Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS)

Introduction

Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) is a critical topic for the MCCQE1 and constitutes a significant portion of the General Pediatrics and Preventive Medicine objectives. It falls under the broader umbrella of Sudden Unexpected Infant Death (SUID).

⚠️

Definition: SIDS is defined as the sudden death of an infant under one year of age which remains unexplained after a thorough case investigation, including performance of a complete autopsy, examination of the death scene, and review of the clinical history.

In Canada, SIDS remains the leading cause of post-neonatal death. Understanding the epidemiology, risk factors, and Canadian Safe Sleep Guidelines is essential for the Health Advocate and Medical Expert CanMEDS roles.

Epidemiology and Canadian Context

While the incidence of SIDS has decreased significantly since the introduction of the “Back to Sleep” campaign, it remains a major public health concern in Canada.

Peak Incidence: Between 2 and 4 months of age.
Gender: Slight male predominance (3:2).
Seasonality: Higher incidence in winter months (associated with overheating and respiratory infections).
Vulnerable Populations: Indigenous infants in Canada have a rate of SIDS significantly higher than the national average, highlighting the importance of addressing Social Determinants of Health.

The Triple Risk Model

Current understanding of SIDS pathophysiology is based on the Triple Risk Model. SIDS occurs when three factors intersect:

Vulnerable Infant: Underlying defect (e.g., brainstem abnormality in serotonin signaling).
Critical Developmental Period: Rapid growth and homeostatic instability (2-4 months).
Exogenous Stressor: Environmental factors (e.g., prone sleep, overheating, nicotine exposure).

Risk Factors

Identifying risk factors is high-yield for MCCQE1 preparation. These are categorized into maternal, infant, and environmental factors.

Maternal Factors

Maternal Smoking: The single most significant modifiable risk factor (dose-dependent response).
Substance Use: Alcohol and illicit drug use during pregnancy.
Young Maternal Age: <20 years old.
Poor Prenatal Care: Late or no prenatal care.
Short Inter-pregnancy Interval.

MCCQE1 High-Yield Alert

Smoking during pregnancy and in the postnatal environment is one of the strongest risk factors. Prone sleeping is the strongest modifiable environmental risk factor addressed by the “Back to Sleep” campaign.

Differential Diagnosis

Since SIDS is a diagnosis of exclusion, other causes of sudden unexpected death must be ruled out.

Category	Conditions to Consider	Key Clinical/Autopsy Findings
Cardiac	Long QT Syndrome, WPW, Myocarditis	Family history of syncope/sudden death, abnormal ECG (post-mortem genetic testing).
Metabolic	MCAD deficiency, Urea cycle disorders	Failure to thrive, history of lethargy, hypoglycemia, fatty liver on autopsy.
Infection	Sepsis, Meningitis, Pneumonia	Fever, signs of infection, positive cultures.
Trauma/Abuse	Non-Accidental Injury (NAI), Suffocation	Retinal hemorrhages, rib fractures, inconsistent history.
Neurologic	Seizures, Brain malformations	History of abnormal movements.

Prevention and Management: Canadian Guidelines

The Canadian Paediatric Society (CPS) and the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) have issued a Joint Statement on Safe Sleep. Mastery of these guidelines is essential for the exam.

The ABCs of Safe Sleep

AAlone: No bed-sharing, no toys, no loose bedding.
BBack: Always place the baby on their back to sleep.
CCrib: Use a crib, cradle, or bassinet that meets Canadian regulations.

Detailed Recommendations

Sleep Position: Supine (back) for every sleep. Side sleeping is not safe. Once an infant can roll over consistently (usually 4-6 months), they do not need to be repositioned.
Sleep Surface: Firm mattress with a tight-fitting sheet. No bumper pads, pillows, comforters, or stuffed animals.
Room-Sharing: Recommended for the first 6 months of life (protective effect).
Bed-Sharing: Not recommended by the CPS due to risk of entrapment/overlaying, though culturally practiced by some.
- Harm Reduction: If parents choose to bed-share, counsel strictly against it if: infant <4 months, born preterm/LBW, or if parents smoke, drink alcohol, or take sedating drugs.
Breastfeeding: Protective effect against SIDS.
Pacifier Use: Use at nap and bedtime is associated with reduced SIDS risk (mechanism unclear, possibly increased arousal or airway patency). Delay until breastfeeding is established.
Overheating: Dress the infant in light clothing; no hats indoors.
Home Monitors: Cardiorespiratory monitors are not recommended for SIDS prevention in healthy infants.

Counselling Parents: A Step-by-Step Approach

Step 1: Assess Current Practices

Ask open-ended questions: “Tell me about where and how your baby sleeps.” “What do you usually do when the baby wakes up at night?”

Step 2: Acknowledge and Validate

Acknowledge that parents are tired and trying their best. “I know it is exhausting when the baby wakes up frequently.”

Step 3: Educate on Risks and Guidelines

Explain the “Why” behind the guidelines. “We know that babies who sleep on their tummies are at higher risk of not waking up if they have trouble breathing.”

Step 4: Address Barriers

If parents bed-share, explore why (e.g., ease of breastfeeding). Discuss safe alternatives like a bassinet right beside the bed.

Step 5: Reinforce Protective Factors

Encourage breastfeeding and a smoke-free environment.

Medical Abbreviations


SIDS  = Sudden Infant Death Syndrome
SUID  = Sudden Unexpected Infant Death
SUDI  = Sudden Unexpected Death in Infancy
ALTE  = Apparent Life-Threatening Event (Historical term)
BRUE  = Brief Resolved Unexplained Event (Current term)
MCAD  = Medium-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency
CPS   = Canadian Paediatric Society
PHAC  = Public Health Agency of Canada

Key Points to Remember for MCCQE1

Diagnosis of Exclusion: SIDS cannot be diagnosed without a full autopsy and death scene investigation.
Back to Sleep: The most effective public health intervention.
Smoking: The most significant modifiable risk factor (prenatal and postnatal).
Sleep Environment: Firm surface, no loose items, room-sharing without bed-sharing.
Monitors: Do not prevent SIDS; do not prescribe them for this purpose.
Grief: In the event of a SIDS death, the physician’s role includes compassionate communication, avoiding blame, and arranging follow-up/counselling.

Sample Question

Clinical Scenario

A 6-week-old male infant is brought to the clinic for a routine well-baby check. The infant was born at 39 weeks gestation via spontaneous vaginal delivery and has been growing along the 50th percentile. The mother is breastfeeding exclusively. During the visit, the mother mentions that her mother-in-law insists the baby should sleep on his stomach to prevent a flat head and choking on spit-up. The mother admits she is confused and asks for your advice. She also mentions that she sometimes brings the baby into her bed to nurse and falls asleep.

Which one of the following statements is the most appropriate advice to provide regarding sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) risk reduction?

A. Side sleeping is a safe alternative to prone sleeping to prevent aspiration.
B. Bed-sharing is recommended to facilitate exclusive breastfeeding and enhance bonding.
C. Home cardiorespiratory monitors should be prescribed to alert the parents if the infant stops breathing.
D. Supine sleeping (on the back) is the safest position and does not increase the risk of aspiration.
E. Prone sleeping is acceptable during daytime naps if the mother is in the room.

Explanation

The correct answer is:

D. Supine sleeping (on the back) is the safest position and does not increase the risk of aspiration.

Detailed Explanation:

Option D is correct: Placing the infant on their back (supine) for every sleep is the single most effective action to reduce the risk of SIDS. Evidence shows that healthy babies placed on their backs are less likely to choke on vomit than those on their stomachs. The trachea lies on top of the esophagus when supine; gravity prevents regurgitated milk from entering the airway.
Option A is incorrect: Side sleeping is unstable; infants can easily roll onto their stomachs, placing them at high risk for SIDS. It is not a recommended alternative.
Option B is incorrect: While room-sharing is recommended, bed-sharing (co-sleeping) is not recommended by the Canadian Paediatric Society due to the risk of entrapment, overlaying, and suffocation, particularly in an infant <4 months old.
Option C is incorrect: There is no evidence that home cardiorespiratory monitors reduce the incidence of SIDS in healthy infants. They should not be used for this purpose as they can provide a false sense of security.
Option E is incorrect: Prone positioning is a major risk factor for SIDS. Infants should sleep on their backs for all sleep periods, including naps. “Tummy time” is only for when the infant is awake and supervised to prevent plagiocephaly and assist motor development.

References

Canadian Paediatric Society. (2021). Joint Statement on Safe Sleep: Reducing Sudden Infant Deaths in Canada. Retrieved from CPS.ca
Public Health Agency of Canada. (2021). Safe Sleep for Your Baby.
Moon, R. Y. (2016). SIDS and Other Sleep-Related Infant Deaths: Evidence Base for 2016 Updated Recommendations for a Safe Infant Sleeping Environment. Pediatrics.
Medical Council of Canada. (2024). MCCQE Part I Objectives: Pediatrics.